Hertz – The Rental Car Giant That Collapsed (2020): A Case Study in Debt Mismanagement and Industry Disruption

Lesson: A Bad Debt Strategy Can Bankrupt Even a Market Leader

Introduction
Hertz, one of the world’s largest and most recognized car rental companies, filed for bankruptcy in May 2020 after accumulating $19 billion in debt and struggling to adapt to market disruptions. The company’s failure was accelerated by the COVID-19 pandemic, which severely impacted travel demand, leaving thousands of rental cars sitting idle.

This case study explores the key issues that led to Hertz’s bankruptcy, the consequences of its financial struggles, and important lessons for businesses on debt management and innovation.

Key Issues Behind Hertz’s Bankruptcy

Hertz’s collapse was a result of poor financial decisions, failure to adapt to changing consumer behavior, and external economic shocks.

1. Excessive Debt Without Digital Transformation

• Hertz accumulated $19 billion in debt, primarily to expand its rental fleet and finance corporate acquisitions.
• The company failed to invest significantly in digital transformation, leaving it behind competitors in app-based reservations and contactless rentals.
• The debt burden left Hertz with little financial flexibility to handle unexpected crises.

2. Failure to Adapt to Industry Disruptors (Uber & Lyft)

• Rideshare services like Uber and Lyft drastically reduced demand for short-term car rentals, particularly in urban areas.
• Instead of adapting its business model, Hertz continued relying on traditional airport-based rentals, ignoring shifting consumer preferences.
• The rise of subscription-based mobility services further threatened Hertz’s relevance in the changing transportation landscape.

3. COVID-19 Crushed Travel and Rental Demand

• The global pandemic shut down travel, leaving airports empty and Hertz’s rental fleet largely unused.
• Revenue plummeted almost overnight, making it impossible to service its massive debt obligations.
• Hertz’s already precarious financial position meant it couldn’t weather the crisis, leading to bankruptcy.

Consequences of Hertz’s Collapse

The fallout from Hertz’s bankruptcy had significant financial, operational, and industry-wide effects.

1. Bankruptcy Filing and Mass Layoffs

• In May 2020, Hertz filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection, becoming one of the largest corporate failures during the COVID-19 crisis.
• Thousands of employees were laid off, further impacting an already struggling labor market in the travel industry.

2. Selling Off Fleet to Stay Afloat

• To generate cash, Hertz sold off large portions of its rental fleet, leading to a flood of used cars on the market.
• This move temporarily helped the company survive, but also reduced its ability to operate at full capacity post-pandemic.

3. Restructuring and Rebounding with Electric Vehicles

• After securing new investors, Hertz emerged from bankruptcy in 2021, implementing a major restructuring plan.
• The company shifted focus toward sustainability, announcing a 100,000-car purchase from Tesla, signaling a strong commitment to electric vehicles (EVs).
• Hertz rebranded itself as a modern mobility company, integrating digital innovations and sustainability efforts.

Key Takeaways for Businesses and Financial Management

Hertz’s fall and recovery provide crucial lessons for businesses on financial discipline, industry adaptation, and crisis resilience:

• High debt limits a company’s ability to handle crises: Over-leveraging can leave businesses vulnerable when unexpected economic downturns occur.
• Ignoring industry disruptors leads to decline: Companies must continually adapt to new competitors and shifting consumer behaviors.
• Diversification and digital innovation are critical for survival: Investing in technology and alternative business models can help companies stay ahead of market trends.
• Restructuring and innovation can help companies recover: A well-executed turnaround strategy, including strategic partnerships and sustainability initiatives, can restore profitability.
• Flexibility and agility are essential in uncertain markets: Businesses must be financially and operationally agile to withstand industry shocks and economic downturns.

Discussion Questions and Answers for Business Professionals & Students

Q1: What were the main reasons behind Hertz’s bankruptcy?

A: Hertz’s bankruptcy was primarily caused by high debt, failure to adapt to industry disruptors like Uber and Lyft, and the collapse of travel demand during COVID-19.

Q2: How did Hertz’s debt contribute to its financial collapse?

A: With $19 billion in debt, Hertz had limited financial flexibility, making it difficult to survive the revenue losses from the pandemic.

Q3: What strategic mistakes did Hertz make in response to the rise of Uber and Lyft?

A: Hertz ignored the rideshare revolution, failing to innovate its rental model or explore partnerships with emerging mobility services.

Q4: How did Hertz manage to recover after bankruptcy?

A: Hertz restructured by cutting costs, selling assets, securing new investors, and investing in electric vehicles (EVs) to modernize its fleet.

Q5: What lessons can other companies learn from Hertz’s experience?

A: Businesses should maintain manageable debt levels, adapt to industry changes, invest in innovation, and build resilience for economic downturns.

Final Thoughts: The Importance of Financial Strategy and Industry Adaptation

Hertz’s bankruptcy and recovery illustrate how poor debt management and resistance to market trends can lead even a dominant company to collapse. However, the company’s strategic pivot toward electric vehicles and digital transformation demonstrates that with innovation and adaptability, businesses can rebuild stronger.

For business leaders, financial analysts, and students, this case underscores the need for sustainable financial planning, continuous innovation, and proactive adaptation to industry disruptors.

Stay connected with SignifyHR for more insightful case studies on corporate finance, crisis management, and business strategy!